# Campaign platform: The scorebook

One idea for three rooms. The decks do not invent a second one.

Credit: Serge Shima, CC BY 4.0. Method and case library from [github.com/smixs/creative-director-skill](https://github.com/smixs/creative-director-skill).

## Brief

First Draft. The vision line: one product to build everything amateur football. The people in the room change. The idea does not.

Three businesses already exist and have no shared system. Private tournaments (team fee, prizes, sponsors). Pickup (slot, fee, waitlist, cancel). Corporate (an auction, no payment setup). The ground is a real role in the same product. Public scores and history sit open, in the manner of a live-score app. The crew is the player, the host, the ground, the auctioneer, and the rest. Live scoring, player stats, summaries, media kits, and payments where money moves. XP is a rating people can feel. Personal targets (games, goals, distance) are the player's own record. The emotional core: amateur football is never written down. At 70 you should still have the goals.

Rooms: partners and investors, organisers (clubs, hosts, tournament organisers), the internal team. Channels in this pass: three 16:9 decks, three 15s openers, one 15s 4:5 social film to firstdraftfc.com.

Constraints that bind the work: pitch black, Neon Turf as the only action colour, Trophy Gold only when something was earned, Manrope and JetBrains Mono, programme language, no emoji, no exclamation marks, no middot, no em dash, say contribution never donation. No market-size figures, no revenue, no customer logos, no Bengaluru club counts as platform traction. The public film may only say what the live homepage says. `proof` stays empty.

Idea level, Pollard: a brand platform (what the company stands for, measured in years), articulated here as a campaign platform the three rooms can execute. Not a seasonal campaign. Not a feature list.

Working territory, tested rather than locked: people already keep the record of clubs they only watch. Nobody keeps the record of the club they play for.

## Insight

Pollard, in order.

Problem. The week of amateur football happens and then it is gone. Fees, the list, the score and the goal live in a chat, on paper, or in one person's head.

Insight. Amateur players want the same written record the clubs they only watch already have, but the week they play is never written down, because the archive was built for spectators.

Advantage. First Draft can give that week the grammar a league already uses: a page, a live score, a season, and gold only when something was earned. Pickup, the private cup and the corporate room are three editions of one book.

Strategy. Treat the club you play for with the seriousness already spent on the club you only watch. Write the week down, so the goal is still there at 70.

JTBD. Functional job: get the list, the money and the score into one place. Social job: the group looks like a club, not a thread. Emotional job: the goal still exists when the chat is gone. The competitors for that emotional job are memory, a camera roll and a dying group chat. Not another booking app.

Tensions.

- Cultural. We archive the clubs we watch, and we treat the club we play for as a hobby that expires.
- Category. Sports products promise the game and deliver a broadcast of someone else's.
- Human. You want the goal at 70. The only copy is a message that will be deleted.

How might we.

- Broad. How might we give amateur football the archive professional football already takes for granted?
- Medium. How might we make the club you play for feel as recorded as the club you only watch?
- Narrow. How might a Thursday game leave a line a player can still read at 70?

Rung. Medium. "The record" is concrete enough to design and wide enough for three businesses. The narrow rung is the last slide, not the platform.

The working territory holds. It is the insight. It is not the tagline. Said plainly, it is a sentence a player recognises and has not quite said.

## Ideation

Primed against the canon before generating. Cases read in full:

- TMB Bank, Panyee FC, 2011. Patterns P13 and P16. A real floating pitch, borrowed as proof that a bank believes in people who try. Emotion: bittersweet pride. Steal that was refused: we do not borrow someone else's true story to make a brand point. The product is the record.
- Xbox, Football Decoded, 2018. Patterns P05 and P09. The watched game, explained through a game people play on a screen. Opposite direction. The subject here is the club you pay to play for, not the match you decode from the sofa.
- Spotify Wrapped, filed under P18 as the personal-record cousin. A yearly poster of a catalogue you already consumed. The unit here is the week, and if the week is not written it does not exist. There is no December drop to lean on.

Pattern pressure. P13 (truth telling) has 87 cases in the library. P03 (behavior inversion) has 44. P16 (long-form drama) has 261. P18 has 33. A blunt "nobody records amateur football" line is sub-canon. A yearly wrap is a cousin, not a gap. The gap is the object and the subject: a weekly page, for the club you play for.

Methods, pass 1, from the brand-platform triplet: SIT, bisociation, provocation PO. The first three ideas are warmup and were not developed.

1. Warmup, SIT subtraction half-done. "Your season, finally." A stats promise. Any rival can say it.
2. Warmup. "From the chat to a league." A migration story the category already tells.
3. Warmup. "One app for every kind of amateur football." A feature list. Not an idea.
4. SIT subtraction. Remove the spectator. A table with your own name on it.
5. SIT task unification. Booking the slot and paying the fee are the same act as writing the page. You do not log the game afterwards. Playing it writes it.
6. SIT attribute dependency. Gold appears only when something was earned, so the visual system is part of the idea. A dashboard would kill it.
7. Bisociation, with a family album. At 70 you open the season the way you open a drawer.
8. Bisociation, with a ledger. Every week leaves a line: who played, who paid, what the score was.
9. Bisociation, with a live-score app. Strangers arrive the way they arrive at a score. They stay because the name on the page is theirs.
10. Provocation. The clubs on television are the amateur ones. The form belongs to the Tuesday game, and we give it back.
11. Provocation, killed in the same pass. "A goal that is not written down did not happen." Uncomfortable, and unfair to the host. The product cannot promise every touch was captured.
12. The ordinary week, honoured. Not the final. The Tuesday nobody filmed.

Ideas 1 to 3 dropped as warmup. Idea 11 dropped on voice and on ethics. Ideas 7, 9 and 10 carried the tension into scoring.

## Scores

Axis 1, brief compliance, for the finalist: one sentence, the message reads, the insight survives, each room can hear itself, the three businesses and the crew are in it, the voice holds, the product can support it without fake traction. Pass.

Pass 1. "Give the record back." The archive was built for spectators. Point it at the club you play for.

| Criterion | Score |
| --- | --- |
| Originality | 7.5 |
| Strategic fit | 9.0 |
| Emotional response | 8.5 |
| Feasibility | 9.0 |
| Scalability | 9.0 |
| Simplicity | 8.5 |
| Weighted | 8.48 |
| HumanKind | 7 |
| Grey | 7, original |

Why it is not a 9. Originality sits in a saturated truth-telling pattern. "We track your stats" is what nine teams in the category would say. Emotion is specific (the missing goal at 70) but the object is still vague. HumanKind is 7 because the act is the product: remove the product and the cultural object is not there yet.

Pass 2. Method rotation to SCAMPER. The object becomes the page. "The week gets a page." Pickup is the weekly edition. The private tournament is the event edition. The corporate auction is the closed edition. Public scores are how a stranger opens it. Eliminate the dashboard. If it looks like admin, the idea died.

| Criterion | Score |
| --- | --- |
| Originality | 8.0 |
| Strategic fit | 9.2 |
| Emotional response | 8.8 |
| Feasibility | 9.0 |
| Scalability | 9.0 |
| Simplicity | 9.0 |
| Weighted | 8.75 |
| HumanKind | 7 |
| Grey | 8, best in category if the page is unmistakable |

Delta from pass 1: 0.27. The object is sharper. Originality still is not a new mechanic. It is a clearer one.

Pass 3. Secondary method rotates to synectics. Direct analogy: the cricket scorebook. Amateur cricket has kept the week in a book for a century. Football, the game with the most complete spectator archive on earth, does not keep the club you play for. Personal analogy: you remember the goal and you cannot prove the date. Fantasy analogy, used as the last line and not as a promise of magic: at 70 the Tuesday is still on the page.

| Criterion | Score |
| --- | --- |
| Originality | 8.4 |
| Strategic fit | 9.2 |
| Emotional response | 9.0 |
| Feasibility | 9.0 |
| Scalability | 9.0 |
| Simplicity | 8.8 |
| Weighted | 8.87 |
| HumanKind | 7 |
| Grey | 8 |

Emotional response reaches Tier 3: bittersweet pride. The book should have existed. It can exist now. You will not get the years that were never written. Delta from pass 2: 0.12. The idea has plateaued. A further tenth would be scoring inflation.

Pass 4. Stimulus rotates to worst idea, as a check, not a rescue. "Burn the chat" is hostile to the organisers who live there. A physical page posted after every week raises originality and fails this brief: the rooms need a platform they can say on a slide, and the product is software. Neither beat 8.87. Stopped. Criterion (c) is close, and a fifth pass on the same insight would decorate it.

HumanKind stays 7. The scale says below 7 is not presented. 7 is a HumanKind act that still needs the product in order to exist. It is presented with that limit in the open, not dressed as a 9. No Cannes-grade claim. The idea stands next to Wrapped only to mark the difference (week, not year; the club you play for, not a catalogue you consumed) and next to Panyee only to refuse the borrowed-documentary move.

Pattern calibration. Closest pattern is P13, with a P14 lean: the page is the proof, not a film about a pitch. Difference from the canon: the unit is the week, the subject is the club you pay to play for, and the three businesses are three editions of one book. Gold is a rule, not a theme. That variant is enough to clear "sub-canon". It is not enough to clear a 50-case originality cap, and P13's saturation was respected in the 8.4.

Pre-mortem, run on the locked line before the decks were built.

| Failure | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The live site is one club, and a public line about "everything amateur football" is a lie | High | High | The social film says only what firstdraftfc.com says. The vision stays in the decks, labelled on the team map. |
| A sample leaderboard is read as traction | High | High | `proof` is empty. Counts and names the homepage marks as sample stay out. |
| "A goal unwritten did not happen" insults the host | Medium | High | That line is dead. The host writes the page. The product does not scold the missing one. |
| Investors ask for a market size | Medium | Medium | The category is structure, not a number. No TAM, no revenue, no logos. |
| It still sounds like a stats app | Medium | High | The decks use programme language. The object is the page. Admin cards are refused. |

Verdict: go, with those mitigations. They are built into the decks and the film.

## Platform

### Strategic foundation

- Objective. Give partners a category, give organisers their week back, and give the team one map that does not blur vision into code.
- Insight. Amateur players want the same written record the clubs they only watch already have, but the week they play is never written down, because the archive was built for spectators.
- Territory. The scorebook of the club you play for.
- Positioning. First Draft writes the week an amateur club actually plays, in the same programme a league already uses.

### Concept

- Big idea. The club you play for gets a record.
- Line the rooms share. The club you play for gets a record.
- Object. The page. A week is a page. A season is the book.
- Visual language. Pitch black. Neon Turf for action and kickers. Trophy Gold only for what was earned: the goal kept, the honour, the centre of the mark. Manrope 800, tight, last word outlined on a section title. JetBrains Mono for kickers, indexes and labels. Huge numbers, small labels. No cards.
- Tone. Plain, specific, unhurried. Example phrase: "The week gets a page."

### Architecture

| Level | Idea | Where it lives |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Brand | The club you play for gets a record | All three rooms |
| Partners | Three businesses, no book. Strangers arrive by the public score. They stay for the page. | Investors deck and opener |
| Organisers | You already write this by hand. The page keeps the chase, the match day, and the goal. | Organisers deck and opener |
| Team | One map. Solid is in the code. Outline is the brief. | Team deck and opener |
| Public film | Only the live homepage. One club, one fee, one season. | 4:5 social |

### What each room must not do

Partners do not receive a market size, a revenue line, a customer logo, or a Bengaluru count dressed up as traction. Organisers do not receive a lecture about chats. The team does not receive a blurred roadmap. The public film does not receive the three-segment vision, a grounds marketplace, corporate auctions, or personal targets.

## The three rooms

### Partners and investors

The category is three businesses that already run, and none of them has a book. Pickup is the habit and the weekly page: a slot, a fee, a waitlist, a cancel. The private tournament is the event: a team fee, prizes, sponsors. The corporate auction is the closed room: the same tournament, no payment setup. Public scores are how a stranger opens the programme, the way they would open a live-score app. Money, the ground and the page are why they stay. The crew is named: player, host, ground, auctioneer, scorer. XP is a rating a player can feel. Personal targets are the player's own record, said as the point of the book, not as a shipped count. Close on the product line: one product to build everything amateur football, and on the goal that is still there at 70.

### Organisers

The pain is the chasing. Fees, the waitlist, the dropout, the team sheet, a score written on paper. Show the three ways they already run football. Then match day: the roster, the live score, the crew. Then what players leave with: goals, assists, appearances, and a kit they can post. Corporate is the same tournament without a payment setup. The ground sits on the same page, and the books can pay it. Where money moves, say contribution, never donation. Close on the season that remembers the goal.

### Internal team

One map. Three segments. Roles as the code has them. Two planes, public and signed in. The add-on switches, by their names in code: auction, xp, matchdayKit, chipIn, watch. A platform default, then the community, then the tournament.

Mark vision against the code. Two gaps stay labelled, not blended.

1. The live homepage, https://firstdraftfc.com/, is one Bengaluru club. Book a slot, balanced sides, a season, XP, ₹200 a session, Play 365. It is not platform traction. The repo landing talks like a platform. The live URL does not. The public film follows the live URL.
2. The XP rubric in code is the platform's. `loadXpRubric` reads one platform row. The schema says the rubric itself stays the platform's. The brief asks for a matrix per community. That matrix is not in the code.

Same honest label, after a pass through the code:

- Personal targets (games, goals, distance): not in the code. Vision.
- Calories: not in the code. Vision.
- A public history browser, open like a live-score app across clubs and seasons: not in the code. What exists is narrower. `/live` follows public games as they are played. A club can open one game so anyone with the link can follow the score. The season hub (table, scorers, results, earlier seasons) sits inside the signed-in club shell.

What the code does write, so the map is not only gaps: booking, waitlist, cancel, balanced sides, live scoring, a crew (host, co-host, scorer), club owner and admin, treasurer, auctioneer, platform admin, season stats inside the club, a media kit, an auction, chip-in, a watch path, and grounds a platform admin curates. A community can request a ground. The books can pay a ground (`GROUND_OUT`). A ground is a place, not a login. The ground as an operator inside the product is the brief, and it is labelled as such.

Money: integer paise. How a game is paid comes from `payModeOf` and `payByFor` (gateway, manual, choice). The treasurer is the financier. Chip-in is the switch name. The word in the product is contribution.

## Homepage claim note

Checked against the live page https://firstdraftfc.com/ on 19 Oct 2026, not against the platform landing in the repo.

The page says: community football, properly organised. A members' club, weekly 8v8 at Play 365 in Bengaluru. Book a slot. If the game is full you join the waitlist and only pay once a spot opens. Balanced teams, a team sheet before kickoff. Goals, assists, appearances, XP and man of the match. ₹200 per player, per session. No membership fee. A cancel in time returns the fee to the club wallet. Request to join, then approval, then book, then pay.

The page also prints 142 sessions, 968 goals, 51.2k XP, 3,410 appearances, a leaderboard (A. Sharma, R. Menon, K. Iyer, D. Fernandes) and a 111.0 season ring. Under that ring it says the figures are sample, not real members. Those counts and names are not in the film. `proof` is empty. No reviews were invented. No people were invented.

No line in the social film is wider than that homepage. The three-segment vision, the grounds marketplace, corporate auctions, personal targets and the line about 70 stay in the decks.

Asset caveat, once: the live Open Graph image carries the line "Elite 8v8 football community". The page body does not say elite. That image is not used. The films use the brand mark only. No player photography exists on the page that could be used without inventing a person.

## Discarded directions

- A feature tour with the three businesses as a menu. On-brief, and not an idea.
- The unwritten goal as an accusation. Sharp, and it fails the host.
- A physical weekly poster as the campaign object. More original, and not what these rooms are for.
- Any public count from the sample block. It would read as traction. It is not.
